good pizza in indianapolis

3 min read 11-01-2025

Introduction: Your Guide to Indy's Pizza Scene

Indianapolis boasts a surprisingly diverse pizza scene, catering to every craving from classic Chicago deep dish to Neapolitan-style pies. Whether you're a long-time resident or just visiting, finding the best pizza in Indy can feel overwhelming. This guide navigates the city's best pizzerias, highlighting what makes each unique and helping you discover your new favorite slice.

Top Picks for the Best Pizza in Indianapolis

1. Pizzeria Locale: Neapolitan Perfection

Pizzeria Locale consistently ranks among the top pizza spots in Indianapolis. Their Neapolitan-style pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven, resulting in a perfectly charred crust with a slightly chewy texture. The simple, high-quality ingredients shine through in every bite. Their Margherita pizza is a must-try, showcasing the beauty of simplicity.

What makes it special: Authentic Neapolitan style, wood-fired oven, high-quality ingredients.
Best for: Pizza purists seeking an authentic Italian experience.

2. Matt the Miller's Tavern: Upscale and Delicious

For a more upscale pizza experience, Matt the Miller's Tavern offers gourmet pizzas with creative toppings and a sophisticated ambiance. Their pizzas are cooked in a brick oven, imparting a unique flavor to the crust. Their extensive wine list perfectly complements their menu.

What makes it special: Gourmet toppings, brick oven, upscale atmosphere.
Best for: A special occasion or a night out with friends.

3. Bazbeaux Pizza: A Chicago-Style Delight

If you're craving Chicago deep dish, Bazbeaux Pizza is your go-to destination. Their deep dish pizzas are loaded with cheese and toppings, offering a hearty and satisfying meal. Be prepared to wait, as their pizzas are made to order and require some time to bake.

What makes it special: Classic Chicago-style deep dish, generous toppings.
Best for: Satisfying a deep-dish craving. Prepare for a wait!

4. Metazoa Brewing Company: Pizza and Brews

Metazoa Brewing Company combines the best of both worlds: delicious craft beer and excellent pizza. Their pizzas are crafted with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. The relaxed atmosphere makes it a great spot to catch up with friends.

What makes it special: Great beer selection, locally-sourced ingredients, casual atmosphere.
Best for: A relaxed evening with friends enjoying both pizza and beer.

5. Amalfi Trattoria: A Taste of Italy

Amalfi Trattoria is another great option for authentic Italian pizza. Their thin-crust pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven. The crust is crispy and light. The restaurant offers a range of classic and unique topping combinations.

What makes it special: Thin-crust, wood-fired, authentic Italian flavors.
Best for: A classic Italian pizza experience.

What to Look For When Choosing a Pizza Place in Indianapolis

Beyond the specific pizzerias, here are some factors to consider when choosing your perfect pizza experience in Indianapolis:

Crust: Do you prefer thin crust, thick crust, deep dish, or something else?
Sauce: What kind of sauce do you like? Traditional tomato, pesto, or something unique?
Toppings: Are you a meat lover, veggie enthusiast, or somewhere in between?
Atmosphere: Do you want a casual or upscale dining experience?

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the best pizza near me in Indianapolis?

The "best" pizza is subjective and depends on your personal preferences. Use the guide above to find a pizzeria that matches your tastes. Many apps like Yelp and Google Maps allow you to search for pizza places near your current location.

Where can I get the best deep dish pizza in Indianapolis?

Bazbeaux Pizza is a popular choice for authentic Chicago-style deep dish.

What are some hidden gems for pizza in Indianapolis?

While the list above highlights popular choices, exploring smaller, independent pizzerias might uncover your new favorite hidden gem. Checking local review sites and blogs can help you find lesser-known places.

Conclusion: Your Indianapolis Pizza Adventure Awaits!

Indianapolis offers a diverse range of pizza options, from classic styles to innovative creations. This guide provides a starting point for your pizza journey. Don't hesitate to explore beyond these suggestions and discover your own favorite slice of heaven in Indianapolis. Happy eating!